RE: PalTel/ISP Draft Working Paper

["Ibrahim Barham" <ibrahim_barham@safad.com>]

Dear All

We just received Paltel reply yesterday as a reply to our letter which was
sent to them three months ago, and we were surprised that he forwarded their
reply to itsig also. Although it's not professional from them to do that
since it was addressed to me as PITA chairman, but it seems that they did it
in purpose and we are taking that seriously.

By the way, we are working on an official reply for their proposal and we
will keep you informed.

Regards,

Ibrahim Barham, PITA
Chairman


-----Original Message-----
From: Michael Younan [mailto:gse@012.net.il]
Sent: Tuesday, July 31, 2001 5:57 AM
To: sbahour@palnet.com
Cc: members@pita-palestine.org
Subject: Re: PalTel/ISP Draft Working Paper


Is this a PITA matter or ITSIG


If this PITA Matter why address ITSIG, why not address PITA members

If this ITSIG matter then leave PITA out


There must be some line drawn here by PITA members


We are either ITSIG or PITA


Can some one decide from PITA


Soon some of PITA confidential matters will seep to ITSIG and then
what????????? or has it????????

Michael Younan

----- Original Message -----
From: Sam Bahour <sbahour@palnet.com>
To: <Board@pita-palestine.org>; <tareq.maayah@ict.siemens.com>; Ahmed
Abumarzouq <ahmed@p-i-s.com>; <myounes@hally.net>;
<ibrahim_barham@safad.com>; Maan Bseiso <maan@palnet.com>;
<ZahiKhouri@aol.com>; Mousab Khorma <mkhorma@hotmail.com>;
<wnajjab@mcs-palestine.com>; <rohaifa@cabank-pal.com>; nael asad
<nael.asad@paltel.net>; <jamal.salameh@platel.net>; Daoud Daoud
<daoud.daoud@paltel.net>; Suleiman Mashriqi EE-mail"
<suleiman.mashriqi@paltel.net>; <farid.taha@paltel.net>; Nabil Tamimi
<nabil.tamimi@paltel.net>; <khalil.hamad@paltel.net>; Haytham Zuabi
<hzuabi@zaytona.com>; <leith@4san.com>; <ghiath@firstnet.com.jo>;
<mohammad.ali@paltel.net>; AbdelRahman Omar <aromar@paltel.net>;
<general@itsig.org>
Sent: Tuesday, July 31, 2001 1:13 AM
Subject: Re: PalTel/ISP Draft Working Paper


Dear all,

After an initial reading of the first written PALTEL Internet Strategy (2
yrs in
the working and still in draft form) I notice language such as:

1.  In one of Paltel's emails they state that "[their] 'Monopoly' is a
fallacy",
then in their proposed strategy they state:

"Given PalTel's current advantage as the sole supplier of backbone
communication services.."

Humm, that sure sounds like a monopoly position to me...a real one, not a
virtual or fallacy one.  For more on this aspect see attatched analysis from
16/9/2000, only a few weeks prior to Intifada.

2.  "All ISP's must be licensed by ..."

- is this PALTEL's job to define?

3.  "...within a reasonable and specified period of time. PalTel's target is
a
year."

Self-imposed, firm-specifc targets are good, country sector development
targets are larger than any single monopoly operator's view of the world.

4.  "All ISP's should not entertain..."

- Is it PALTEL that defines what other operators can and cannot do?

5.  "..ISP's are not to provide, in any way shape or form, without the
explicit
knowledge and consent of PalTel.."

- Humm, in the post Sept 28 2000 period is PALTEL now the regulator too?

6.  "...PalTel will have the right, and obligation, to target specific
and/or all
ISP's ..."

- to target??!!

I fully agree with Mr. Omar that we should met, as a sector, face to face to
clear the positions on the table.  With the current complete paralysis of
the
PNA, and the historic deficiencies of the MOPT, maybe we can also discuss
using some of PALTEL's profits to build an independent communications
regulatory body as well, especially since competition is on the horizon (or
already on the ground).

Regards,
Sam


On 30 Jul 2001,, AbdelRahman Omar wrote:

> Ibrahim,
>
> Thank you for your correspondence and your kind words.
>
> I included your attached document as a refresher and a recap. Also to put
> this subject into context.
>
> I attached as per your request a Draft Working Paper outlining the
framework
> that I discussed with a number of your colleagues.
>
> I believe we are all in synch and on the same page in terms of our common
> objectives and how to get there.
>
> There remains a few topics that require a dialogue, preferably face to
face, to
> iron out the details of our common understandings and basis for
cooperation.
> These include:
>
> - Mechanisms/Processes for tracking our programs, achievements and
targets. -
> Agree on joint Public Awareness, Public Relations and Advertising
Programs. -
> Incentives/Rewards for the better achievers. Call it Volume
> Discounts....etc...together I am sure we can be very creative.
>
> I look forward to the opportunity to having such a dialogue to finalize
> matters to our mutual, and the End User's, benefits.
>
> Ibrahim, please advise your colleagues about this correspondence and let's
> try to expedite events and get the ball rolling. There are many challenges
> and opportunities facing us all that are just waiting to be addressed.
>
> My best Regards,
>
> Abdel Rahman Omar
> PalTel EVP for Tech Affairs.
>
>
____________________________________________________________________________
> ____________ > -----Original Message----- > From: Ibrahim Barham
> [mailto:ibrahim_barham@safad.com] > Sent: 27/May/2001 01:56 PM > To:
> aromar@paltel.net > Cc: Maan Bseiso; wnajjab@mcs-palestine.com;
> mkhorma@paltel.net; > zahikhori@aol.com; Sbahour; Board; Tareq Maayah >
Subject:
> PITA reply > > > Dear Mr. Abdel Rahman > > First of all, let me introduce
> myself. I am Ibrahim Barham, the chairman of > board of PITA, and I myself
and
> all the board were so happy from the > feedback that we received from our
ISP
> members about the ideas that you were > presenting to them. And to follow
up
> what was discussed, here is attached > our reply to you depending on the
> strategy that was sent to Paltel two years > ago and I was informed that
you
> received it already from our colleagues. > > We are looking forward to
meet you
> so as to finalize this issue for the > benefit of all parties and our
community.
> > > Best regards, > > Ibrahim Barham, PITA > Chairman > > > > > >
>
****************************************************************************
> ********* >  PALTEL E-Safety System scanned this email and found NO
viruses, >
> vandals or malicious content. >
>
****************************************************************************
> ********* > Should you need any information or clarifications regarding
this
> system, > please do not hesitate to contact our team at the Internet
Project >
> <esafety@paltel.net>. >
>
****************************************************************************
> ********* >
>
>
>
>
>
>
****************************************************************************
****
> ***** The contents of this email and any attachments are confidential. It
is
> intended for the named recipient(s) only. If you have received this email
in
> error please notify the system manager or  the sender immediately and do
not
> disclose the contents to any one or make copies.
>
****************************************************************************
****
> ***** PALTEL E-Safety System scanned this email and found NO viruses,
vandals or
> malicious content.
>
****************************************************************************
****
> ***** Should you need any information or clarifications regarding this
system,
> please do not hesitate to contact our team at the Internet Project
> <esafety@paltel.net>.
>
****************************************************************************
****
> *****
>