Time
to pay the piper
Ehud Barak says his country is ready to turn a new
page in its relations with Lebanon, but it will take far more than talk to undo
the damage wrought by 22 years of occupation.
His troops may be gone, but the effects of their presence will take many years
to dissipate, so the "Israeli" prime minister should take
responsibility for his predecessors actions and agree to pay compensation for
the many thousands of Lebanese whose lives have been ruined or ended by
"Israeli" aggression. Having made Lebanon its whipping boy for more
than a generation, "Israel" cannot simply walk away and hope to enjoy
anything like normal relations with this country.
People have been deprived of their loved ones, their homes, their livelihoods,
and most of their human and civil rights. The physical destruction has been
immense, the economic ruin almost total, and the psychological impact
devastating. How does one answer a 5-year-old whose only comment on the
withdrawal is a question: When will "Israel" be back?
Try as he might, if at all, Barak will never be able to make full restitution
for all of the trouble that his country has caused here. He could start,
however, by addressing the most easily quantifiable aspect: the destruction of
property both private and public.
What was, until this week, the occupation zone is quite literally filled with
evidence that "Israeli" actions cost this country billions of dollars
over the years in ruined homes, shops, roads, and infrastructure. This is not to
mention the damage inflicted on priceless assets like Beaufort Castle, or the
bill for air strikes on bridges, power stations, and communications
installations.
From the "Israeli" perspective, the best part about paying
compensation is that it would signal the Jewish states willingness to live by
the very rules that it has sought to have others obey. The "Israeli"
government has put much weight behind the efforts of Holocaust survivors to
reclaim what was wrongfully taken from them during World War II, and it has
promised to seek compensation for Jews whose property was confiscated by Arab
governments in 1948. If it does not pay reparations to Lebanon, how can the
Lebanese listen to the words of Barak and his compatriots with anything but
doubt and hostility?
"Israeli" officials and citizens alike can often be heard to complain
that many governments treat theirs like an international outlaw, but in fact the
Jewish state has benefited from uncommon leniency, thanks largely to protection
afforded it by the United States. Other countries are not simply denied a few
perks at the United Nations when they defy international law: they are slapped
with sanctions and/or bombed into submission. Iraq, for example, killed nowhere
near as many Kuwaitis as "Israel" killed Lebanese, but Baghdad is
still paying the price.
It will take years for Lebanon to get back on its feet, and while much of the
damage was our own doing until 1990, "Israel's" contribution has
been relentless.
The Daily Star, 27-5-2000.